A monastery, probably housing Vallambrosan monks, was here before it became a house of Silvestrine Benedictine monks in 1290. The Silvestrines themselves were later moved to San Giorgio dello Spirito Santo, having been accused of living 'without poverty and without chastity'. They made way for Observant Dominican friars from San Domenico in Fiesole, who took possession of the partially ruined convent and church on March 15th 1436, finding that the Silvestrines had stripped the buildings of their furnishings and burned parts of the buildings. (The Observants were stricter Dominicans than the Conventuals at Santa Maria Novella.) The Medici family had been involved in the church's lavish celebrations of the Feast of the Epiphany, held here since 1417, which featured a procession celebrating the journey of the Magi by a confraternity of which they were members. Cosimo de' Medici may have influenced Pope Eugenius to evict the Silvestrines to facilitate the installation of his favoured Dominicans. The Pope, then installed in Santa Maria Novella, is said to have encouraged Cosimo to fund the rebuilding. The Dominicans rebuilt the whole complex between 1437 and 1452. Michelozzo, the Medici's favourite architect, designed the church, pilgrims' hospice, cloister, library and friars' quarters. Fra Angelico worked here with Michelozzo for eight or nine years, until he was summoned by the Pope to Rome in 1445 to work on the (now lost) decoration of the Chapel of the Sacrament in the Vatican Palace. The church here was consecrated on Epiphany 1443.
The first prior Antonino Pierozzi (1389-1459) became archbishop of Florence in 1446 and was canonised as Saint Antoninus in 1523. A later notable prior here was Girolamo Savonarola.
Vasari later 'modernised' the church, presumably by removing a screen, but it acquired its present form in 1588 to a design by Giambologna, with the facade built 1777-78 to designs by the Carmelite friar Gioacchino Pronti. The Dominicans were expelled in 1866 and the first cloister became a museum in 1869, with nearly all of Fra Angelico's surviving panel paintings moved here in 1921.
The church itself is aisleless and somewhat square, designed by Michelozzo, with four altars on the right and three on the left, the last bay being a chapel more like a transept arm. Some 14th-century fresco fragments between the altars on the left, and to the right of the door on the inner facade is an Annunciation fresco, positioned in emulation of the famed miracle-working Annunciation in Santissima Annunziata. Mostly minor 16th-century altarpieces. The Crucifix which hangs over the main entrance was said to be by Giotto by Vasari, but is now widely thought to be a studio work of c.1310/20. An attribution to Simone di Puccio has also recently been suggested.
On the right the first altarpiece is by Santi di Tito. Next is a Virgin and Six Saints of 1509 by Bartolomeo della Porta (Fra' Bartolomeo). The impressive Byzantine mosaic of the Virgin in Prayer is thought to date from the early 8th century and to have been in the old St Peter's in Rome. Its impact is somewhat diluted by being surrounded by frescoes of saints and putti in imitation of mosaic, added in the 17th century.
The dome was frescoed by Alessandro Gherardini in 1717. The rather baroque wooden ceiling by Pier Francesco Silvani is from 1679. The church originally, and more modestly, copied the burial church of the order's founder, San Domenico in Bologna, in having a wooden roof over the main nave and vaulting over the more holy space for the friars. Two screens originally divided up the space for men, women and friars, with the women kept safely furthest from the friars while they performed the Mass.
The large transept-like chapel is Giambologna's Chapel of Sant'Antoninus, built in 1580 for the Salvin family. The saint is is buried here, at the end on the left, and there is some good mannerist stuff, including an altarpiece of The Descent into Limbo by Allori. Also Il Poppi's Christ Healing the Leper and The Calling of St Matthew on the left and right walls. The murals in the cupola are by Pocetti
The humanists Pico della Mirandola and Angelo Poliziano are interred between the second and third chapels on the left. Their tomb slabs are on the north wall behind the sculpture of Savonarola (see below right) of whom Pico had been an influential ally. (He brought the apocalyptic preacher back to Florence, despite his earlier failure to connect with the people of Florence, an action which led to the arguably the grimmest period in Florence's history.) These tombs were opened in 2007 when their deaths in 1494 being likely from arsenic poisoning was confirmed.
The Coronation of the Virgin of 1402 by Lorenzo di Niccolò, commissioned for the high altar here by the Sylvestrines, was given to the Dominicans of the church of San Domenico in Cortona in 1440 by Cosimo and Lorenzo de' Medici when the Fra Angelico altarpiece replaced it here.
The main panel of Fra Angelico's San Marco altarpiece (1438-40) (see below) painted for the rebuilt church, is now in the museum next door (having returned from restoration, carried out to celebrate the museum's 150th anniversary in October 2019, it having suffered a damaging earlier restoration). It is an early example of the single-filed square pala quadrata and the Medici's first major altar donation in Florence. The frame is lost. Cosimo as patron is not depicted, but is represented by his family's patron saints, Cosmas and Damian. (Cosimo had a twin brother called Damiano who died young.) On the Virgin's right are Saints Lawrence and John the Evangelist, also family patron saints, and Saint Mark, the convent's patron. On her left are Saints Dominic, Francis and Peter Martyr. The altarpiece originally consisted of at least 26 panels, of which 18 remain.
The altarpiece's nine predella panels - seven along the front and one miracle at each end around the corner - depicting scenes from the lives of Saints Cosmas and Damian, mostly the attempts to martyr them, are in many galleries. The Louvre has the gory Martyrdom with the decapitated heads rolling around on the floor still sporting their halos. The Alte Pinakothek in Munich has four panels, including the famous central Entombment, which technically might be called a Pieta and which somehow inspired Rogier van der Weyden's Entombment, commissioned by Cosimo around 1463/4. Munich also has Saints Cosmas and Damian before the Proconsul Lysias and in case you don't know the story the evil Proconsul has his name written on his large red hat. Washington and Dublin have one each, the latter, showing the saints at the stake, also featuring Lysias with his name on his hat. The San Marco museum here has two, including The Dream of Saint Justinian, the posthumous miracle where Cosmas and Damian replace the leg of an amputated man with a black one. The central Entombment panel forms an axis with the Crucifixion panel set into the bottom of the main register and the Christ child.
Eight small full-length saints from flanking supposrts of the frame are to be found in the Lindenau-Museum, Altenburg (which has three), a private collection, Hampton Court and the Cini Collection in Venice. The last two, Dominican saints, one of them Vincent Ferrer, were found in England in 2007 and sold at auction for £1.7m
The Altarpiece of the Purification by Benozzo Gozzoli of 1461-2 was commissioned by the youth confraternity of the Purification of the Virgin and of Saint Zenobius who met in a room off the second cloister here. The main panel of the Virgin and Child Enthroned with Saints and Angels (see right) is in the National Gallery in London and the predella panels are in Berlin, Washington, Philadelphia, the Brera and the Queen's Collection. Gozzoli was a pupil of Fra Angelico and the altarpiece's contract specified that the Virgin should be 'in likeness' with the figure in Angelico’s San Marco altarpiece discussed above. In 1506 the altarpiece was moved to the confraternity’s new oratory nearby and by 1757 was in the refectory of the Ospedale dei Pellegrini in Via San Gallo.
Botticelli's Coronation of the Virgin, an altarpiece originally in the chapel of Sant'Alò here. It was commissioned by the Guild of Goldsmiths and was painted between 1488 and 1490. It's been in the Uffizi since 1796.
Many works by Fra Bartolommeo. His Christ in the Temple (1516), now in the Kunsthistorisches Museum Vienna, had been in the Uffizi but they swapped it with Vienna for Dürer's Adoration of the Magi in 1793. His dark Virgin and Child with Saints was painted for the Santa Caterina altar here, and is now in the Palatine Gallery in the Palazzo Pitti. It was acquired by Grand Prince Ferdinando, who deprived many Florentine churches of their altarpieces, either by providing cash or replacement copies. Also in the Pitti is a huge Sistine-ceiling-inspired panel of Saint Mark by Fra Bartolomeo, acquired from San Marco by Napoleon in 1799. It was mounted on canvas and later returned to Florence. A matching Saint Sebastian, sent to the French king in 1529, is now lost.
Church opening times Monday - Friday 8.15 – 1.20
Saturday 8.15 – 4.20
The San Marco Convent Museum
Upon entering you find yourself in Michelozzo's Cloister of Saint Antoninus, which has quite vivid frescoes in the lunettes by Fra Angelico (the five small ones over the doors in the corners) but mostly they are by an artist called Giovanni Antonio Sogliani, amongst others, painted later and showing scenes from the life of Saint Antoninus, the first prior here. Facing you along the arm of the cloister as you enter is a large fresco of Saint Dominic worships the Crucifix (1442) by Fra Angelico, with added flanking figures of The Mourning Virgin and St John by Cecco Bravo in 1628.
The first room on the right, The Pilgrim's Hospice displays panel paintings by Fra Angelico taken from other (mostly closed or demolished) churches and convents. Completely refurbished during the 2020 lockdown, this room is now called the Sala del Beato Angelico. Carrying on anti clockwise around the cloister takes you to a large refectory with unspecial work along the right-hand wall, a quite impressive fresco of The Last Supper of Saint Dominic (with the Crucifixion taking place above) by our friend Sogliani, a former pupil of Lorenzo di Credi, on the end wall, and more by him up the left side. Instead of the Saint Dominic Sogliani had wanted the main scene to be The Feeding of the Five Thousand and provided a drawing, but the brothers wanted something simpler. Vasari admires the work but says that Sogliani should have been allowed to paint his choice 'because painters express the conceptions of their own minds better than those of others'. Opposite is a small room more worthy of attention with some sweet Fra Bartolomeo panels and his famous dark post-mortem profile Portrait of Savonarola. Fra Bartolomeo was a fellow Dominican and a great admirer of Savonarola, even being imprisoned with him in 1498.
Next around the cloister is a The Chapter House, a square room with a big and lovely Crucifixion fresco by Fra Angelico, but looking much more worked than his usual (see right). It's the largest work that he made here. On Christ's right hand are the group around the Virgin and the Medici patron saints, painted in bright colours. To his left are the founders of religious orders, led by Saint Dominic, painted in duller earth colours, with a bit of blue-black.
The Dormitory and Library
Next is upstairs. On the first floor are the 45 smalls cells containing 40 frescoes for private contemplation painted by Fra Angelico and his studio, including Benozzo Gozzoli. Paintings were seen as essential parts of the Dominican way of prayer, meditation and study.
The large Annunciation at the top of the stairs is justly one of Fra Angelico's most well-known and loved works. It is somewhat austere in colour and traditional in execution, as is fitting for the brothers. The scenes in the cells are even more austere (see below right) to the point of sometimes almost seeming unfinished.
Turning left here takes you down the east corridor, the clerics' dormitory, with the paintings in the cells to the right are all by assistants, but those on the outer, left, side largely by Fra Angelico himself. For the clerics their are scenes from the life of Christ or the Virgin, witnessed by one of the major Dominicans - Dominic, Peter Martyr or Thomas Aquinas - like the Annunciation (right) in cell 3, with Peter Martyr praying behind the Angel. The scenes in the 20 cells of the clerics are more theologically complex than those in the novices' and lay brothers' cells.
This corridor leads to the south corridor, the novices' dormitory, where the images are of Saint Dominic praying before the Crucifixion and are more instructive, as befits the cells of young boys in training. At the end of this corridor is Prior Savonarola's rooms.
Retracing your steps and turning right back at the Annunciation, takes you into the north corridor, the dormitory of the lay brothers' (or conversi), mostly the work of assistants, where the first cell on your left is that of Saint Antoninus. The lay brother' cells all have straightforward narrative scenes from the New Testament, as appropriate for less educated brothers who attended to the community's domestic needs..
On the right you reach the entrance to Michelozzo's famous library. Long lauded as a fine typical Brunelleschi-inspired renaissance interior with its white walls and pietra serena details, the walls were recently discovered, under plaster applied since suppression, to have been green, a colour said to be symbolic of contemplation often used at the time for the walls of libraries. The vaulted aisles and barrel-vaulted ceiling makes this one of the few parts of the complex that doesn't have a wooden ceiling, denoting its importance, and the need to minimise the risk of fire.
Just outside the entrance is a plaque commemorating Savonarola's arrest here on April 8th 1498. At the end of this corridor are the cells used by Cosimo de' Medici, containing an Adoration of the Magi, a characteristic Medici subject, by Fra Angelico with the help of Benozzo Gozzoli, his assistant at the time, who went on to later famously paint the same subject in the chapel of the Medici Palace.
Back down stairs is the Museo di Firenze Antica established in 1898 in the Foresteria (guest quarters) to house architectural fragments from the controversial demolition of the Mercato Vecchio. A fine Last Supper based on a Ghirlandaio's Ognissanti fresco, but here probably mostly the work of assistants, is in the small refectory/gift shop. It was restored in 1994/5 when some oil overpainting was removed. From windows in the corridor you can see into the (not visitable) cloister of Saint Dominic.
Museum opening times Monday - Friday 8.15 - 1.50
Saturday, Sunday and Holidays 8.15 - 4.50
Closed 2nd and 4th Monday and 1st, 3rd and 5th Sunday of each month
Update February 2021 The new Sala del Beato Angelico, formerly known as the Hospice Room, has recently opened to display works on panel by Fra Angelico.
Oltrarno :: Fiesole